The 11 most effective rewards for top tier program members

The true art lies not just in creating a tiered loyalty program but in tailoring its rewards to resonate deeply with your most valuable customer: the top-tier VIP members. 

November 27, 2023

The true art lies not just in creating a tiered loyalty program but in tailoring its rewards to resonate deeply with your most valuable customer: the top-tier VIP members. 

These are your brand's champions, the customers whose ongoing commitment not only drives consistent revenue but also amplifies your brand's presence through their advocacy and influence.

As we explore the most effective rewards for your brand’s champions, remember that the goal is twofold: to acknowledge the VIP's invaluable contribution to your brand and to foster an even deeper, more meaningful connection moving forward. 

Here are our 11 favorite rewards for top tier VIP members : 

  1. Exclusive access to new products
  2. Personalized discounts
  3. Complimentary upgrades on products
  4. Invitation-only events or experiences
  5. Dedicated personal customer service representative
  6. Customized gifts
  7. Access to exclusive content, tutorials, or webinars
  8. Free of expedited shipping
  9. Extended warranty or return policies
  10. Loyalty point multipliers or bonus points
  11. Input on future products

11 most effective rewards for top tier VIP members

1. Exclusive access to new products

When it comes to rewarding your top-tier VIP members, nothing quite says 'exclusive' like granting them first dibs on new products or services.

This privilege creates a feeling of exclusivity and anticipation, that sets your most loyal customers apart from the crowd.

Why It works wonders

First of all, this approach appeals to a fundamental human desire: the love of being first.

It's thrilling to be ahead of the curve, isn't it?

When you offer your VIPs this exclusive preview, you're not just selling a product, you're offering them an experience, a sneak peek into the future of your brand.

Tailoring the experience

How you unveil these new offerings can vary. Think personalized emails or messages that make your VIPs feel like insiders. 

Or perhaps an elegant, invitation-only online portal where they can view and purchase these new offerings. 

The key? Make it personal and make it feel like a red-carpet affair.

Beyond just 'First access'

But why stop there? Accompany this early access with insider info : how the product was made, the story behind it, or tips on getting the most out of it.

This approach not only heightens the exclusivity but also fosters a deeper connection between your brand and its most valued customers.

The ripple effect

And here's the kicker: this strategy often transforms your VIPs into brand ambassadors. 

When they share their excitement about getting something exclusive, it creates buzz. 

It's like triggering a domino effect of interest and desire among the wider customer base.

A word of caution

However, balance is key. You want to ensure that while you're catering to VIPs, you're not alienating your broader customer base. 

It's all about making VIPs feel special without making others feel excluded.

2. Personalized discounts

For your VIP members, the allure of personalized discounts or special pricing offers can be a compelling way to reinforce their loyalty. 

It's not just about saving money. It's about feeling recognized and valued as an individual.

The art of personalization

The magic word here is 'personalized.' 

Generic discounts? Anyone can offer those. 

But when you tailor these offers based on individual preferences, purchase history, or even special occasions like birthdays, you're sending a powerful message: "We know you. We appreciate you."

Dynamic pricing

Consider dynamic pricing strategies.

This isn't about slashing prices across the board. Instead, it's about smart, targeted offers that make sense for both the customer and your business. 

For example, higher discounts on items they frequently purchase or modest incentives on products they've viewed but never bought.

The element of surprise

Sometimes, it’s not just what you offer but how you offer it. 

Surprise discounts or unexpected special offers can create delightful moments. 

Imagine a VIP member receiving a surprise discount on an item they've been eyeing for weeks.

That's not just a discount. It's a memorable experience.

Exclusivity in the offer

Ensure these offers are exclusive to your VIP members.

They should feel like they're part of an elite club with benefits that aren't available to the average customer.

This exclusivity enhances the perceived value of your products and the overall brand experience.

Timing and communication

Getting the timing right is crucial.

Bombarding VIPs with offers can be overwhelming, whereas too few might make them feel neglected.

The communication of these offers is equally important. Personalize the message, make it warm and engaging, not just a cold, transactional email.

Personalized discount email for VIP members

3. Complimentary upgrades on products

Free upgrades for your VIP members are like a pat on the back: "You matter to us.

It's an effective way to show appreciation, making your top-tier customers feel valued and special.

A gesture of goodwill

Think of these upgrades as tokens of your gratitude for their loyalty. 

Whether it's a higher version of a product, an enhanced service, or additional features, these upgrades can significantly enhance the user experience. 

It's a way of saying, "You've invested in us, and now we're investing in you."

Tailoring the upgrade

The key is relevance. Upgrades should align with the customer’s interests and needs. 

For instance, if they regularly purchase software from you, an upgrade to a premium version makes sense. 

For frequent flyers, an unexpected class upgrade can be a delightful surprise.

The element of exclusivity

Ensure that these upgrades feel exclusive. 

They should be perks that are not easily attainable or are usually paid for.

This exclusivity not only adds value to the VIP membership but also sets a clear distinction between regular and VIP treatment.

Building a narrative

When offering upgrades, communicate the story behind it. 

It’s not just about the freebie. It’s about why they’ve earned it. 

A message that acknowledges their loyalty or a significant milestone in their journey with your brand adds a personal touch that can deepen their emotional connection to your brand.

Beyond the product

Remember, upgrades aren’t just about physical products. They can also be about enhancing services. 

Think priority service, faster response times, or exclusive access to premium support.

These service upgrades can often be more valuable than physical goods, especially in service-oriented industries.

4. Invitation-only events or experiences

Invitation-only events or experiences are like the secret spices in your customer engagement recipe.

They offer an exclusive, memorable way to connect with your top-tier VIP members, making them feel part of a privileged group.

Crafting exclusive gatherings

Whether it's a private product launch, a VIP dinner, a workshop with industry experts, or an exotic retreat, these events should offer something that can't be bought off the shelf.

It's about creating an environment where VIPs can engage not just with your brand but with each other, fostering a sense of community.

Personalization is key

Tailor these experiences to match the interests and preferences of your VIP members. 

Are they tech enthusiasts? Host a tech talk with a renowned expert. 

Fashion aficionados? Organize a meet-and-greet with a celebrated designer.

It’s about striking a chord with their passions.

The power of networking

These events offer a golden opportunity for networking, something that many high-value customers appreciate. 

Facilitate interactions that allow your VIPs to connect with like-minded individuals, industry leaders, or even your company's executives. 

This can add immense value to their experience.

Beyond physical events

In today's digital world, don't overlook the power of virtual events. 

Webinars, online masterclasses, or virtual reality experiences can be incredibly engaging, especially for those unable to attend in-person events.

Exclusivity and desirability

The allure of these events lies in their exclusivity. 

They should be seen as coveted invitations, something that sparks excitement and anticipation.

The mere act of being part of such events can elevate a customer's perception of your brand.

A lasting impression

It's not just the event itself, but the memories it creates. 

Thoughtful touches like personalized welcome messages, exclusive event merchandise, or follow-up thank-you notes can leave a lasting impression that turn a single event into a long-term emotional connection.

Invitation-only event example

5. Dedicated personal customer service representative

Providing a dedicated personal customer service representative or concierge to top-tier VIP members is like offering them a VIP pass to exceptional service.

It’s a testament to how much you value their time and satisfaction.

Personalized service at its best

Having a dedicated representative means your VIPs have a go-to person for all their needs.

This is someone who knows their preferences, purchase history, and can offer tailored solutions.

This personal touch transforms customer service from a transaction to a relationship.

Efficiency and exclusivity

Imagine the convenience for your VIPs when they don’t have to explain their background or repeat their issues every time they contact customer support.

Their dedicated representative already knows the context, leading to quicker and more effective resolutions.

Building trust and loyalty

This level of personalized attention fosters trust.

VIP members know they are not just another number in the system but valued individuals. 

This trust is a cornerstone of deep, long-term customer loyalty.

The role of the concierge

A concierge service can take this concept even further.

It's not just about resolving issues but about providing proactive suggestions, exclusive deals, and insider tips.

Think of it as having a personal advisor for all things related to your brand.

Customization is crucial

The effectiveness of this service hinges on its customization.

The more tailored the service to the individual VIP’s needs and interests, the more valuable it becomes.

Regular training and updates for these representatives about VIP members’ preferences are crucial.

A reflection of your brand

This service is a direct reflection of your brand’s commitment to customer care.

It must be flawless, as any missteps can significantly impact the perceived value of your VIP program.

6. Customized gifts

Customized gifts or merchandise for your top-tier VIP members are a tangible way to show appreciation and create a lasting brand connection. These personalized items serve as a constant reminder of the special relationship between your brand and your most loyal customers.

The personal touch

Customization is key. The more personalized these gifts are, the more impactful they become. 

This could range from monogrammed products to items tailored to the VIP’s hobbies or interests. 

The aim is to make the VIP feel that this gift was crafted just for them.

Quality speaks volumes

The quality of these gifts is paramount. They should not only be unique but also reflect the high standards of your brand.

Premium quality ensures that the gift is valued and cherished.

This reinforces the perception of your brand as one that prioritizes excellence.

Beyond conventional merchandise

Think outside the traditional merchandise box. 

Instead of standard branded items, consider gifts that offer a unique experience or utility. 

For instance, a custom-designed piece of technology for your tech-savvy VIPs or a limited-edition item that’s not available to the general public.

Timing and occasion

The timing of gift-giving can amplify its impact. 

Surprising your VIPs with a gift on a special occasion like an anniversary or a holiday adds an emotional dimension to the gesture.

It shows thoughtfulness and attentiveness to details that matter to them.

Packaging matters

The presentation of the gift is almost as important as the gift itself.

Elegant packaging not only enhances the perceived value of the gift but also makes the unboxing an exciting and memorable experience.

7. Access to exclusive content, tutorials, or webinars

Exclusive content, tutorials and webinars are a powerful way to add value to your VIP members' experience of your brand. 

This approach goes beyond physical rewards.

It offers intellectual or educational benefits that can enrich their lives and deepen their engagement with your brand.

Curated for curiosity

The content should be carefully curated and relevant to their interests and needs.

It could range from in-depth tutorials related to your products, behind-the-scenes looks at your brand, to webinars featuring industry experts discussing topics they care about.

An educational edge

This approach is particularly effective because it offers more than a product; it offers knowledge and expertise.

For instance, if you’re a tech company, providing advanced tutorials on technology trends can be immensely valuable to tech-savvy VIPs.

Exclusivity in learning

Ensure that this content is exclusive or early-access to your VIP members. 

This exclusivity makes the content more desirable and underscores the VIPs' special status. 

It's not just about what they learn, but also about being part of an elite group that has access to this information.

Interactive and engaging

Make these educational experiences interactive. 

Live Q&A sessions, forums for discussing webinar topics, or personalized feedback on tutorial exercises can significantly enhance engagement.

It transforms passive learning into an active, community-building experience.

Regular updates and variety

Keep the content fresh and dynamic.

Regularly update the offerings and vary the formats – from videos and articles to live webinars and interactive workshops.

This variety keeps your VIPs engaged and looking forward to what’s next.

Webinar example for VIP members

8. Free or expedited shipping

When it comes to VIP benefits, offering free or accelerated delivery is a simple yet highly effective strategy.

It’s a practical benefit that resonates well with customers, emphasizing convenience and respect for their time.

The convenience factor

In today’s fast-paced world, convenience is king. 

Free shipping removes a common barrier to purchase, while expedited shipping caters to the immediate gratification that many customers seek.

It’s about making their shopping experience as smooth and hassle-free as possible.

A tangible saving

Let’s not overlook the tangible monetary benefit of free shipping.

It’s a direct saving for your customers. 

This makes their VIP status not just a matter of prestige but also of practical, financial value.

Expedited shipping : a step further

While free shipping is great, expedited shipping takes customer service a notch higher.

It’s particularly appealing for last-minute purchases or for those times when your VIP members just can’t wait to get their hands on your products.

Setting the right expectations

It’s important to be clear about the terms of these shipping perks. 

Whether it’s free shipping on all items, a minimum purchase requirement, or specific conditions for expedited shipping, transparency is key to maintaining trust and satisfaction.

Balancing costs

While offering these shipping perks, it’s crucial to balance the cost implications for your business.

Strategic decisions, like offering these benefits only on certain items or during specific periods, can help manage costs while still providing value to VIP members.

9. Extended warranty or return policies

Extended or enhanced warranty or return policies are an excellent way to convey trust and assurance in your products and services.

This benefit not only provides peace of mind but also demonstrates your commitment to customer satisfaction and product quality.

Added assurance

Extended warranties or enhanced return policies give your VIPs an extra layer of security.

Knowing that they have a longer period to return a product or that they're covered for potential issues beyond the standard warranty period can be a significant deciding factor in their purchases.

Customizing the policy

Tailor these policies according to the nature of your products and the needs of your VIP members. 

For high-value items, a longer warranty period can be particularly appealing. 

For lifestyle or fashion products, a more flexible return policy might be more valued.

Building trust

By extending these policies for your VIP members, you’re sending a clear message: you stand firmly behind your products.

This confidence in your offerings can, in turn, bolster the customers' trust in your brand.

A competitive advantage

In a crowded market, an extended warranty or a more customer-friendly return policy can set you apart.

It’s an added value that can sway customers in your favor, especially those who are risk-averse or looking for long-term value in their purchases.

10. Loyalty point multipliers or Bonus points

Loyalty point multipliers or bonus points for your VIP members are a dynamic way to incentivize and reward their continued patronage.

This approach not only encourages repeat purchases but also adds an exciting, gamified aspect to the shopping experience.

Amplifying the rewards

Loyalty point multipliers increase the number of points a VIP member earns per dollar spent, accelerating their journey to valuable rewards

 Bonus points, on the other hand, can be awarded for specific actions like referrals, special occasions, or reaching certain spending thresholds.

Encouraging engagement

This strategy encourages more frequent and higher-value purchases.

Knowing that they are earning points at an accelerated rate or are close to earning bonus points can motivate VIP members to choose your brand over competitors.

Tailored to spending patterns

Customize the multiplier or bonus point system based on individual spending habits. 

For high-frequency shoppers, offer multipliers that reward regular purchases.

For big-ticket buyers, bonus points on large purchases can be more appealing.

Beyond purchases

Extend the earning potential beyond just purchases.

Allow VIPs to earn points for reviews, social media engagement, or participation in surveys. 

This will make the program more interactive and engaging.

Clear communication

Ensure that the rules and benefits of the points system are communicated clearly. 

Transparency in how points can be earned and redeemed is key to maintaining trust and enthusiasm in the program.

Creating a sense of urgency

Introduce limited-time offers such as double points events or special bonus point campaigns to create a sense of urgency and excitement.

This can lead to spikes in customer engagement and sales.

Bonus point email example

11. Input on future products

Offer your VIP members the opportunity to give their feedback on future products or services, for example through beta testing.

It’s a unique way to deepen their engagement and make them feel part of your brand journey.

Involvement in innovation

Inviting VIPs to participate in beta testing or to provide feedback on upcoming products gives them a sense of ownership and involvement in the innovation process.

It’s a powerful way to show that their opinions are valued and that they play a role in shaping the brand’s future.

Exclusive insider experience

Being part of a select group that gets to experience and influence new offerings before they hit the market is an exhilarating experience for customers.

It elevates their status to that of brand insiders and trusted advisors.

Constructive feedback loop

This opportunity isn’t just beneficial for the VIP members; it’s invaluable for the brand too. 

The feedback gathered from these engaged and knowledgeable customers can provide critical insights that help refine products or services before their full launch.

Recognition and rewards

Recognize and reward the contributions of these VIP members.

Acknowledging their input publicly (with their permission) or offering them exclusive perks for their participation can further enhance their sense of belonging and value.

Continuous engagement

Keep these members updated on how their feedback is being implemented.

This ongoing communication can turn a one-time beta test into a long-term engagement, keeping VIPs connected and invested in your brand’s evolution.

Broadening the scope

Consider extending this opportunity beyond just product testing.

Invite them to contribute ideas for new services, improvements to customer experience, or even branding initiatives.

This inclusivity can lead to innovative ideas and strategies that might not have been considered otherwise.

Recommended for you👇