The old marketing funnel assumed that consumers narrowed their choices step by step until one name was left. Real decisions rarely work that way: people add brands while they research, change course after the order and return without looking elsewhere. The consumer decision journey describes that loop, which, unlike a funnel, keeps turning.
✅ Key takeaways
- McKinsey introduced the consumer decision journey in 2009 to replace the linear funnel, because consumers add and remove brands throughout their decisions.
- The model has four phases: initial consideration, active evaluation, moment of purchase and post-purchase experience, plus a loyalty loop.
- Satisfied customers skip the first two phases, and Loyoly's Loyalty Benchmark 2026 shows members place +121.5% more orders over 12 months.
- Price matters: 61% of 1,016 French consumers say it influences their first order from a new e-shop.
- To improve the journey, interview customers, map online and offline touchpoints, prioritise fixes and track one or two metrics per phase.
What is the consumer decision journey?
The consumer decision journey is a model of how consumers move from a first need to a purchase and, after it, to customer loyalty or to a new search. McKinsey introduced it in 2009 to replace the linear funnel, after observing that today's consumers add and remove brands throughout the decision process, and that what happens after the sale shapes their next decisions.
The consumer decision journey has four phases (initial consideration, active evaluation, the moment of purchase and the post-purchase experience) and a loyalty loop that lets satisfied customers come straight back. Customer journeys differ by product, so the same model looks different for a lipstick and for a sofa. It is a framework for understanding consumer decision-making, not a fixed path: customers move through it in their own way, and the steps they take depend on the product, the price and their past experience.
How McKinsey's model differs from the traditional marketing funnel
The traditional model assumes that consumers start with many brands and narrow them down until they order, and that marketing moves them from one step to the next. McKinsey's research showed three differences. First, the number of names can grow during research, as consumers discover new ones through reviews, articles and social media. Second, consumer-driven touchpoints such as word of mouth and online reviews weigh as much as advertising. Third, the journey does not end at checkout: the experience after the order decides whether customers return.
For marketers and business teams, that changes where the budget goes. Instead of spending most of it on awareness, a company has to help customers while they compare options and look after them once they have bought, because the customer experience after the sale is now part of marketing.
The four phases of the decision journey
Initial consideration: which brands buyers think of first
When a need appears, customers start with a short list of names they already know, based on past experience, advertising, shops they pass and what friends use. Being on that first list is an advantage, but no longer a decisive one: names that are missing can still join it later in the consumer decision journey, especially companies like yours that help customers understand their options with clear advice and honest reviews.
Active evaluation: researching and comparing the options
In this second phase, customers research their choices, read reviews and a comparison guide or two, ask friends and visit shops or websites. This is where the list changes most: some names drop out, new ones come in. The winners at this stage provide clear information, honest comparisons and the kind of proof people trust, such as customer reviews and user-generated content.
Moment of purchase: choosing a brand and buying
At checkout, the decision often comes down to practical factors like price, availability, delivery time, returns and the buying experience itself. A slow payment page or an unclear delivery date can still send customers to a competitor at the last step, which is why the purchasing process deserves as much attention as the advertising that started the journey.
Post-purchase experience: assessing whether expectations were met
After the order, customers compare the product and the service with what they expected. This phase shapes the next decision: a good experience opens the way to a repeat order, a poor one sends the customer to the start of the decision journey with one name fewer on the list. Delivery, product quality and after-sales services all count here.
How the loyalty loop shapes repeat purchases
The loyalty loop is the shortcut satisfied customers take next time: they skip the first two phases and return straight to the brand. McKinsey distinguishes active loyalists, who buy again and recommend the brand, from passive loyalists, who come back out of habit but remain open to competitors.
The business value of that shortcut is large. According to Loyoly's Loyalty Benchmark 2026, programme members place +121.5% more orders than comparable non-members over 12 months. A rewards programme turns passive loyalists into active ones by rewarding repeat orders, reviews and recommendations, and a digital loyalty card keeps the brand in the customer's phone between two orders. To see why that matters for growth, read why loyal customers matter and how to keep them.
The loyalty loop lets satisfied customers skip research and come straight back, and a rewards programme makes that shortcut stick: Loyoly's Loyalty Benchmark 2026 shows members place +121.5% more orders than non-members over 12 months.
What influences consumer choices at each stage?
Each phase of the consumer decision journey comes with its own drivers, and understanding them helps marketing decide where to act. Price remains the first: according to Loyoly's Industry Report 2025, 61% of the 1,016 French consumers surveyed say price influences their decision to order from a new e-shop for the first time. The table below sums up the main influences and what to do at each stage.
| Phase | Main influences | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| First list | Past experience, advertising, friends | Stay visible where the need appears |
| Comparison | Reviews, comparisons, shop visits | Provide clear information and proof |
| Checkout | Price, availability, delivery, returns | Remove friction from the buying process |
| After the order | Product quality, service, follow-up | Meet expectations and reward repeat customers |
The key is to treat these influences as one system: a strong first impression is wasted if the checkout fails, and a smooth checkout is wasted if the product disappoints. Digital technology has also changed the balance of power: tools like comparison sites, peer reviews and AI assistants offer consumers access to more information than any sales team, so the companies that win are those that help customers in making better purchasing decisions, not those that try to control the message.
A worked example: choosing and buying a washing machine
A family's washing machine breaks down. In the first phase, they think of two brands: the one they had and one they saw in a shop. While comparing, they read reviews, check energy ratings and capacities, and add a third brand that appears in several review articles. At checkout, the deciding factors are the delivery date, free installation and the removal of the old machine.
After the order, installation goes smoothly and the manufacturer sends a short email with care advice and a reminder to register the warranty. Years later, when the family needs a dryer, they skip the research and go straight to that maker: the shortcut of loyal customers at work, and a clear illustration of how the consumer decision journey can end in a single step.
How to map and improve the journey
Research customer needs using interviews, feedback and behavioural data
Start by understanding how your own customers decide. Interview recent customers about which other companies they considered, which ones they would consider for the next order and why they picked yours, read customer feedback, and use analytics data to see which pages and channels they used before ordering. Together, these resources and your customer data reveal the real customer journey rather than the one the marketing team imagines, and the insights help every team act on facts. Identify the key moments where customers hesitate, understand why, and learn what would have made their purchasing decisions easier.
Map online and offline touchpoints, motivations and friction
For each phase, look at the whole buying journey, not just the steps you control, and list the places where customers interact with your brand online and offline, what motivates them and where friction appears. Mapping the customer journey this way often reveals gaps between channels, such as an offer seen on social media that the shop does not know about. Note which interactions engage customers and which ones drive them away. The guide to the omnichannel customer journey explains how to connect those points, and the purchase journey article covers the stages before the first order.
Prioritise marketing and experience improvements across the journey
Rank the problems by their impact on decisions and by the work needed to fix them. Many companies invest heavily in awareness and too little in what happens after the order, although that is where repeat business starts. Set marketing and customer experience priorities together, so the strategies for each phase support the same customers instead of competing for budget, and test each change before rolling it out. A simple approach is to view each phase in terms of what customers need to understand, then create one action for each need across the customer journey, from the first advert to the returns process.
Measure progress with stage-specific metrics and customer feedback
Track one or two metrics per phase: brand awareness and share of search for the first phase, comparison page visits and review ratings while customers compare, conversion rate and basket abandonment at checkout, repeat order rate and programme activity after the sale. Add customer feedback at each stage to understand the numbers, and review the whole consumer decision journey at least once a year, because new channels, AI assistants and new buying habits change it over time. The customer journey changes faster than most strategy documents, so treat the map as a living tool: the best teams update it whenever data shows a new pattern, and plan future marketing strategies from what customers really do.

.png)







.webp)

.webp)







